List of reviews made by users for the A Depressed Kendo Player Possesses a Bastard Aristocrat novel.
45 users have written reviews for the A Depressed Kendo Player Possesses a Bastard Aristocrat novel and rated it with an average score of 3.7 out of 5. Our novel is ranked 32nd among all the novels in the Light Novel Pub platform.
45 Reviews
Simple, sweet, imperfect, sad. Great story, give read. the one and only reason this book isn't rated 4. 9 stars is because people who it's tailored for are the silent type. they don't want to go through the strain of writing a passage of text for others to read. real life is already enough judgement for them. also, people who think this is cringe are just people who cant understand what true mental degradation feels like. after and during COVID, i was so mentally strained that i was actually insane. I talked to myself, muttered weird sh*t under my breath, stared at people as they walked by. honestly, most would say I belonged in a psych ward if they had video footage of me back then. this book describes about 2/3 of how difficult it is for a person who acts like a sh*t head not to hate themselves.
I understand that this is not for everyone, but if you like character development and that the mc is actually human and has feelings, this is for you Every major side character as their unique personality, and they actually act like real people, the heroines unique, they all feel and show their feelings in diferent ways, they are not just blindly in love with the mc, even though i hate harem i can accept this one the mc is not overwhelming strong, just strong enough, he's constantly getting pannic atacks but they are justified, he's hated beacuse of his past and his image doesnt just gets clean, hes really working for it, not just that, but also the broken relationships that he has, it took time for them to get fixed, and some dont even go back to what they used to. The mc is not a cold and i'll manage alone type of dude, he strugles he needs moral support hes warm, hes caring and he is completly broken, but thats the beauty of it I know is biased but this novel is just great, strongly reccomend
my first review ever post honestly this kind of novel is not for everyone. it targets the readers that may have mental health issues and those that are close to people who have mental issues. this is not the typical novel were you get reincarnated and get revenge and get op along the way. i wont spoil but since its targeted to some specific people I'll say who can read them and appreciate them. this novel contains hard hitting rollercoaster of emotions. it can lead you to happiness and sadness back and forth real quick. those who dont have much struggles in real life or lets say your life is blessed with food, shelter, family and friend wont appreciate much. but to those that lacks among these words or if you feel like your sad. then this might be yours to read. but i wont promise or say that you'll like it 100%. but appreciating it might be the correct word for it. Reminder: This novel is a Heart Warning to read. that's all. also, this novel is for depressed people like me.
It was a good read. There was a lot of mental health scenarios, every other chapter someone was either crying or having a panic episode butttt, i can say that it was satisfying to read . Though slightly cringe , it was a heartwarming read. This was a story of basically the protagonist resolving the ghost of past. I loved this and hope it gets the recognition it deserves. ☺️
Honestly, how much you like this book will entirely depend on your personal tastes. At times, i can imagine the story to be unpleasant for readers who do not enjoy certain clichés. I enjoy reading the book, but with all due respect, i can only give it a 3/5, mainly due to the fact that. . well, its nothing groundbreaking, the story is lackluster in some parts, the world building is not as fleshed out as some other masterpieces on this site, and the characters, especially the female characters, as is kinda typical in korean transmigration webnovels, are nothing special, to put it nicely. Most of the story is what most of you have already read in other novels of a similar kind. Pretty much the only remarkable twist being that the protagonist has some serious trauma. But credit where credit is due; The novel is not garbage. In fact, its quite enjoyable if you dont mind the occasional panic attacks of the protagonist. Literal panic attacks, not the figurative type. So far, i have not really discovered any aggravating plot-holes. The translation is good too, rarely will you find grammatical errors. All in all, as long as your expectations are not too high, you will not be suffering while reading the novel.
I know it isn't for everyone but the book is interesting enough, mc is pretty dramatic at times but considering his mental health issues it makes sense that he is mentally unstable. Will admit that for those who don't understand that the mc just goes from 0 to 300 in a snap. The mc is not mentally stable so don't expect him to act like he is. Solid top 20 books I have read (ik this seems low but I have easily read over 200 books)
If you have snowflake like mentality and doesn't want to mature as a man , read this. This is your true calling. My point is that this one is a very low quality one. Author just put unnecessary of overuse depression , misunderstanding plot to extreme. He wants everything to be very sentimental. So I hereby declare that "This Sh*t so *ss"
-
124d
Bro I know some people with this same mentality and it's very emotional for several people,you gonna say you have a snowflake like mentality to a depressed guy and he'll be very hurt,you think expressing your opinion is worth hurting others?
it's not a masterpiece, how ever it's a excellent read and pass time. The author is very good at expressing depression and emotions in general. -1 for common troupes like harem , academy etc
Its not perfect, but I would say that it is a good novel. Its very emotional, and doesn't deserve a rating of 3. 8. I would say at worst it is a 4, and at best a 4. 2. It does have its tropes, but the emotions in the writing are just great. And it is one that actually has emotion in it, and will make you feel, so if you are into suffering and t*rt*r*, go ahead.
-
151mo
... Bro I'm sorry but instead of replying to your comment i accidentally reported it 💀 ... I mean the admins are smart so your fine but I might get a warning...
2. 5/5 It's not a bad novel per se, but it's just the fact that it's so painfully plot convenient and consists of all the repetitive generic tropes. It's definitely a decentish read to pass the time, but beyond that, if you're looking for a good novel, this ain't it.
-
151mo
Is 2.5 considered average? Cuz based on your opening statement " it isn't a bad novel per se" means the novel itself doesn't suck and based on the rest of your review, I'm getting that the novel doesn't have anything too great and mostly mid. How does it compare to other novels you have read?
you mean heart warning
You gonna say all that and give it 3 stars?